Ideating additional pathways for chestnut mycoforestry

Chestnut roots are colonized spontaneously by many species of edible ectomycorrhizal fungi, not just King Bolete/Porcini. Also for the people who are really into Chestnut-King Bolete mycoforestry, it’s relevant to know that King Boletes co-occur with certain other culinary species of ectomycorrhizal fungi. There’s a complex picture emerging as we learn more, which suggests many possible directions to take follow-up research to our Chestnut-Porcini project. Your input on these ideas is certainly welcome!

Before we begin, I want to restate “The Compatible Genera Generalization”, which led us to look for and discover the association between Castanea mollissima and Boletus variipes fagicola in the first place! Stated plainly, if one species in an EMF genus is known to pair with one species in a tree genus, it follows that pairings of other species from those two genii will most likely be possible, and most likely be feasible if the EMF species is a generalist. In Asia, the King Bolete species Boletus bainiugan associates with the Chinese chestnut. This postulate from mycoforestry community of practice should be applied to all the genii that we discuss below.

Without further ado, let’s talk about moss. Then let’s talk about Sweetbread Mushrooms, Shrimp Brittlegills, Amethyst Deceivers, Weeping Milkcaps. Then let’s get into the complex topics regarding the following: Truffles and Broadleaf Helleborine; Stubby Brittlegills, Lobster Mushrooms and Ghost Pipes; Shrimp-of-the-Woods and Honey Mushrooms. Finally, we’ll touch on a controversial topic- an edible species known as the Blusher, in the generally dangerous or deadly genus of Fly Agaric.

Moss, a facilitator of strong mushroom fruiting!– what’s the deal with seeing moss and Boletus together? Is it just easier to notice brown Boletes across a green background of moss? Possibly, but also, Delicate Fern Moss grows where it’s moist and shady, and forms a dense biological layer acts as a physical shield that blocks direct airflow and sun exposure at the soil surface, slowing down water evaporation from the earth underneath. This would help make the soil under oaks and chestnuts be more suitable for mushrooms to fruit, because normally soil under oak trees is pretty dry in the wild which is bad for mushroom fruiting.

Thuidium delicatulum, “Delicate Fern Moss” is a non-fungus indicator species for King Boletes in the Route 9 Cooperative chestnut orchards. We have also seen different moss species associated with King Bolete observations of Boletus, on iNaturalist, in Ohio. For instance, we have seen Spoon-leaved Moss, Bryoandersonia illecebra; Lesser Smoothcap Atrichum angustatum; Seductive Entodon Moss Entodon seductrix– identifications of moss accidentally captured in iNaturalist observations of Boletus were made for us by members of the Ohio Moss and Lichen Association.

If we find Boletus spontaneously in the forest, or wish to inoculate it there, it might makes sense to start growing moss on the surface of the soil in the surrounding area, in order to maintain a favorable soil moisture regime, which I would hypothesize could facilitate stronger edible ectomycorrhizal fungi fruiting events- in the future. I’m not aware of people growing moss for this purpose, but people do get moss patches started for other reasons- ecological restoration, beautification, etc. I should note this observation from an ecologist Bill Borovicka at Vinton Furnace Experimental Forest. To paraphrase: “I usually see moss on the ground in a line, where the moss used to be growing on a downed tree, and that tree has entirely decomposed into the soil, leaving a living moss mat on top.”

Click to access Resource001310_Rep1715.pdf

Lamarre, J., Joudrier, J., & Rochefort, L. (2023). A propagation technique for native tundra bryophytes for Arctic ecosystem restoration. Arctic Science, 9(4), 819-832.

Formuzis, J., & Titus, J. H. (2010). Moss and soil substrates interact with moisture level to influence germination by three wetland tree species. Wetlands, 30(2), 241-250.

Sweetbread Mushroom, aka the Miller, aka the Spy. An EMF known as The Miller, The Spy, or The Sweetbread Mushroom- Clitopilus prunulus– is considered a strong indicator species for the King Boletes in Europe and the Pacific Northwest. The Spy has a grey to white cap, decurrent gills, and pink spores.

Shrimp Brittlegill. Russula xerampelina, “Shellfish-Scented Russula” These are distinctive brittlegills- there are not other species that both have the reddish coloration on the stem, and also smell like shrimp. Choice edible, growing in Ohio chestnut orchards at Route 9 Cooperative.

Amethyst Deceiver Laccaria ochropurpurea or Laccaria amethystina. The caps of these charismatic mushrooms are considered choice edibles by some. This species has been found to grow on the roots of American Chestnut, and has been found in the Route 9 Chestnut orchards. Laccaria laccata has also been found in these orchards. Sometimes the purple fades over time, and the Amethyst Deceiver just looks like a Deceiver. The Deceiver’s cap is edible too.

The Bradley, or the Weeping Milkcap. As the inimatable Walter Sturgeon said: “Lactarius and Lactifluus are two genera of macro fungi that exude a liquid (latex) when the gills or upper stem are cut. They are closely related to the Russula genus. They form a symbiotic relationship with various trees including oaks, beech, and conifers. They fruit from May to October and are most abundant in July through September. Until recently they were all considered to be in the genus Lactarius. Tasting the latex of a milk mushroom is a feature in identification. The mild tasting species are edible (Badger emphasis added). There are some good edibles here and unlike their Russula cousins, they are usually free of larvae. The brownish orange capped Leather Back or Bradley, Lactifluus volemus has abundant, mild, sticky, tasting, whitish latex which will stain most surfaces (including hands) brown. The flesh and latex have a fishy odor which disappears during cooking.  An edible lookalike, Lactifluus hygrophoroides, has gills that are distant to subdistant. Another similar edible species is Lactifluus corrugis, which has a darker, wrinkled cap and has gills that are darker as well. All three of these occur with oaks. Lactifluus hygrophoroides also occurs with hemlock often along streams.” Does this species grow with Chinese chestnut? Well, it appears to grow abundantly in Ohio with oaks, and abundantly in Greece with European chestnut… Here’s the citation: Diamandis, S. & Perlerou, C. (2001), “The mycoflora of the chestnut ecosystems in Greece,” Forest Snow and Landscape Research 76(3): 499–504. The paper lists Lactarius volemus among the mycorrhizal fungi recorded in chestnut ecosystems; its methods state that mycorrhizal specimens were collected in pure chestnut stands. Lactarius volemus is the former name for Lactifluus volemus. This supports an ecological association with chestnut stands, though it is not, by itself, molecular confirmation of a direct root-level partnership. There is also evidence that chestnut roots being colonized by Lactifluus can prevent ink disease, which is caused by the soil-borne fungus Phytophthora. This is a bigger deal for European/Sweet Chestnut and American Chestnut more than it is Chinese chestnut, but it’s still worthy to note that this mycorrhizal association is effectively part of the chestnut’s immune system.

Tuber- truffle- these things are a bit of a vampire on the tree but they’re more prevalent than originally thought. Vermont chestnut orchards with Epipactis helleborine, broad-leaved helleborine, indicator species for truffle mycelium (Tuber sp.), implications for multi-cropping edible truffles. When you see the helleborine in your orchard, there are probably truffles growing already, secretly. It takes a specially trained dog or pig to find these truffles ordinarily. If you know anyone with a truffle dog who might like to work with us, please help get us in touch..

Lobster Mushrooms and Ghost Pipe-The unusual mycoheterotrophic plant known as the Ghost Pipe, Monotropa uniflora, has been seen abundantly in Pennsylvania chestnut orchards by our friend Noah Vincent. Ghost Pipe is often getting its photosynthate nutrition from a fungus in the Russula genus- Brittlegill Mshrooms. Usually or at least quite often, it’s the short-stemmed Russula aka the Stubby Brittlegill, Russula brevipes, that the Ghost Pipe is hooked up to. The already edible Stubby Brittlegill can be parasitized by a bright orange mold, Hypomyces lactifluorum, and transformed into the much tastier Lobster Mushroom. This is pretty much the same thing as we see happening with Aborted Enteloma turning Honey Mushrooms into the more palatable Shrimp of the Woods. Meanwhile, Ghost Pipe tincture is being used and sold by contemporary herbalists for relieving pain, grief and anxiety. So one could start by inoculating chestnut seedlings with Stubby Brittlegill or other Brittlegills, then when the mushrooms come up you can scatter Ghost Pipe seeds and spray the fruiting bodies of the Brittlegill with a slurry of the Lobster Mushroom. This sounds like a really fun project, doesn’t it?

Shrimp-of-the-Woods. Entoloma abortivum. Shrimp-of-the-Woods are delicious, choice mushrooms, that are actually parasitized forms of Honey Mushrooms Armillaria mellea. The aborted forms are called carpophoroids (fun word). Because Honey Mushrooms are parasitic on tree roots, Shrimp-of-the-Woods are probably not necessarily a good choice for mycoforestry in a nut-focused orchard, because their host is a pathogen of Fagaceae trees and could weaken Chinese chestnut roots. Armillaria mellea growth rate is negatively impacted by Entoloma abortivum infection. White oaks, red oaks and sugar maples are all valuable hardwood trees that are more susceptible to Honey Mushroom parasitization when stressed. Perhaps Shrimp-of-the-Woods could be introduced to timber stands or orchards where Honey Mushrooms infestation is already problem, in order to check the proliferation of Honey Mushrooms and produce this choice edible. “-Entoloma abortivum, “Shrimp-of-the-Woods” if there are Armillaria mellea, “Honey Mushrooms” present. “Entoloma is infecting Honey Mushrooms, and those odd-shaped fungi are actually malformed Honeys. The ecological role of this interaction hasn’t yet been confirmed, but it’s possible that Entoloma abortivum serves as a natural, biological control for Armillaria species, which cause a fatal tree disease called Shoestring Root Rot… Shrimps are mild-tasting and nice pan-fried to a golden brown or cooked in your favourite broth or soup, where they’ll absorb the flavors.” Quote from https://www.pei-untamed.com/post/shrimp-of-the-woods

The Blusher- use caution!- controversial! Only the most risk-tolerant members of Ohio Mushroom Society will cook up a Blusher. We only mention it because it’s closely related to the classic fungal “indicator species” for King Boletes- Fly Agaric, Amanita muscaria, and Caesar’s Mushroom Amanita caesarea. There is is mycoforestry product in Italy (Myco Chest) includes the edible Amanita caesarea and Boletus edulis together. These species may or may not occur in Ohio. We have observed Amanita muscaria var. guessowii on the roots of Chinese chestnut, and we’ve seen the fruiting bodies appear in the chestnut orchard. This is not an edible, is poison, and can make you delerious, though of course there is a strong ethnobotanical record of human usage for visionary experiences. I suspect Amanita amerirubescens “The American Blusher” has been found in association with Boletus in North America, but at this point this is only a hunch since I haven’t yet observed it. This is a blushing amanita in the A. rubescens– which Europeans enjoy eating, and which I harvested from a European Beech and European Chestnut area in the Basque country on our trip to Iberia. The Blusher is of this sub-grouping of Amanita that bruises reddish-pink when touched or injured. If you are examining Amanita found near Boletus to key it, you can double check for this reddish-pink bruising.

We have talked about a lot of different pathways for further mycoforestry research and practice. I hope this conversation helps articulate various trailheads that we could take together, or that others can take. Please get in touch if you would like to collaborate on these or other mycoforestry efforts!